Top 10 Popular Shot & Shooter Recipes - The Intoxicologist (2024)

Today, September 22, marks the day for the fastest drinking record; Dustin Phillips of the United States consumed a 14 ounce bottle of Ketchup through a 1/4” straw in 33 seconds flat ten years ago. Ketchup seems a nasty ‘beverage’ to guzzle willingly, yet many enthusiastic participants flock to bars weekly to start (or end) the evening with the downing of a shot that none would eagerly sip slowly enough to take in the flavor or texture for a lingering moment on the tongue. Admittedly there are many shot recipes that make the conversion to co*cktail easily. The Oatmeal Cookie shot is an outstanding example.

However, many prefer shots and shooterstoo horrid to down without holding the nose or throwing them back feverishly with a beer chaser or *gasp* water back. I know…I mentioned the word ‘water’ in a co*cktail post. Ghastly! Yet, there are a few shot recipes that make the rounds of Top Ten Popular Shots, most searched for and ‘first one to come to mind’ when asked for best known mixed shot rather than straight liqueur (such as Jager or Zwack).

Buttery Nipple

1 ounce Butterscotch Schnapps

1/2 ounce Irish Cream

Pour Butterscotch Schnapps in bottom of a shot glass. Carefully layer Irish Cream on top to float. Shoot it!

At one time the Buttery Nipple was a favorite of mine, but I never could quite ‘shoot it’ due to the total sweetness of the concoction. I would sip it warm and end up with sticky lips. All the better with Baileys ‘Listen to Your Lips’ campaign. But the Buttery Nipple happens to be rather nice on the rocks with a pleasant rum addition. So, tweaking it just a bit…

Tweaked Buttery Nipple – recipe adapted by Cheri Loughlin, The Intoxicologist

1 ounce Rum

1/2 ounce Butterscotch Schnapps

1/2 ounce Irish Cream

Build in the order given over fresh ice in a rocks glass. Add a stir stick.

Irish Car Bomb

1 pint Guinness Beer

1 shot Irish Cream

1 shot Irish Whiskey

Fill a pint glass two-thirds full of Guinness. Fill a *double shot glass with Jameson and Baileys. Drop the shot glass into the Guinness and chug its entirety immediately. *Use a plastic shot glass to prevent shot glass from chipping when dropping into the glass or bumping against your teeth when chugging.

I’ve not had the best experience with Irish Car Bombs. The realization that many people love them is astonishing since the Irish Cream curdles instantly in the beer glass. But hey, the Irish Car Bomb makes the top ten list of Best Shots for a reason. It’s a popularity contest and this one wins it.

Red Headed slu*t

1 ounce Cranberry Juice co*cktail

1/2 ounce Peach Schnapps

3/4 ounce Jägermeister Herbal Liqueur

Combine all ingredients in a co*cktail shaker with ice. Shake to blend and chill. Strain into a large shot glass. Take this one fast for the sheer pleasure.

Is it the name, the taste or a little of both that get a rise out of the shot crowd? The Red Headed slu*t goes for the mix of a co*cktail, yet shoots straight for excitement.

Jello Shots

2 packages Gelatin (flavor of choice)

1 cup Vodka

Mix gelatin according to package instructions, except substitute vodka for the cold water in process. Use small plastic cups for forming gelatin into shots. Place in refrigerator or freezer. Whipped topping optional garnish for fun just before serving. Jello shotsgo contemporary with newer finger food style gelatin shots in the Mexican Truffle bite-sized dessert.

Lime flavored Jello shots fit in nicely for a green themed St. Patrick’s Day. Other favorite gelatin flavor favorites include Black Cherry, Blue Mixed Berry, Pineapple, Red and Orange according to Facebook and Twitter feedback.

My go-to choice container for gelatin shots are soft plastic condiment cups with lids. They’re transportable and stack well in the refrigerator or in a cooler. Check out the portioned cups I use here: 100 sets – 2oz Plastic Portion Cups with Lids

A fun way to serve gelatin shots is in plastic syringes made specifically for this use. I serve gelatin shots in plastic syringes at my annual Halloween party. Guests love them! The syringes are easy to clean so they can be reused time and time again. Tip: Soak syringes in hot water prior to using. This helps make the plastic pliable so they seal better. Though they hold 1.5 ounces of liquid, I prefer to fill them 3/4 way full. Check out the syringes I use here: 50 pack plastic syringes with lids – 1.5 ounce

blow j*b Shot – There are almost as many variations to this bachelorette party shot requirement as there are ways to blush while trying to order it at the bar. You know how it goes…the most timid member of the group has to order the shot and the bartender ‘pretends’ not to hear the order four or five times until the poor girl is practically screaming for a blow j*b Shot above the rest of the crowd. The frivolity just doesn’t stop since this shot requires the bride-to-be to find some tall, dark, handsome stranger to sit perfectly still while she places the blow j*b Shot between his knees and she takes the shot while on her knees without the use of her hands. The party just never stops… until that is the bride-to-be decides she wants a Screaming org*sm, but that’s really just another shot.