40 Crumbl Cookie Recipes to Recreate at Home (2024)

This Crumbl Cookie copycat recipe brings the tropics to your kitchen! Rich coconut-flavored sugar cookies are topped with chilled lime buttercream. The combination of sweet coconut cookies and tart lime buttercream icing will be a hit! I served these cookies at a Hawaiian-themed party, and everyone loved them!

My favorite part about Crumbl Cookies is that they make any dessert into cookie form! Churros are a classic fried Spanish dessert. This Crumbl Cookie copycat recipe incorporates the delicious churro flavors into a cookie! A thick, sweet cinnamon cookie is iced with a thick cinnamon buttercream frosting for a delicious bite!

Crumbl Cookies are known for their out-of-the-box cookie flavors. While these outrageous flavors are fun, I cannot beat a classic chocolate chip cookie. The large size and chewy texture of a Crumbl Cookie chocolate chip cookie cannot be beaten! I love this recipe because it is as simple as any chocolate chip cookie but twice as delicious!

I was never a fan of Cosmic Brownies, but I had soccer teammates in high school who ate them before every game. The rich brownies are the perfect base to make a Crumbl Cookie! This copycat recipe tastes just as good, if not better than a Little Debbie Cosmic Brownie! Rich chocolate cookies are topped with fudge icing and sprinkled with the signature colorful sprinkles of a Cosmic Brownie.

These pink velvet are the perfect Crumbl Cookie copycat recipe for Valentine’s Day! Their beautiful pink color and sweet flavor scream love. They are flavored with almond extract to give them a twist in flavor. A rich cream cheese frosting goes onto the large, pink cookies for an attractive look to the delicious cookies!

Red velvet and pink velvet are different things. When I first saw these two recipes, I thought the only difference was the food color used! Unlike pink velvet cookies, red velvet cookies have cocoa powder for a rich chocolate flavor. These red velvet cookies are a striking red color and studded with white chocolate chips.

This recipe confused me when I first saw its name. Snickerdoodles are originally a cookie but have been adapted into a cupcake. Crumbl Cookie took this one step further and converted those cupcakes back into cookie form in Crumble Cookie fashion. These large snickerdoodle cookies are piped with a rich, cinnamon buttercream frosting.

Crumbl Cookie understands the childhood most of us lived. Their Mom’s Cookies are oatmeal cookies loaded with peanut butter chips, chocolate chips, and toffee bits. These cookies are called Mom’s Cookies because they incorporate random ingredients many mothers find in their pantry and throw into the cookies. This copycat recipe will have you coming back for another taste!

Cinnamon rolls are one of my favorite desserts. My mom’s homemade cinnamon roll recipe is hard to beat. I saw this copycat recipe for Crumbl Cookie Cinnamon Roll cookies and knew I had to try it. Sweet cookies are topped with a cinnamon spread and piped with sweet icing. They taste like a cinnamon roll in cookie form!

Key lime pie is my favorite summer dessert. The tart lime custard with the crunchy graham cracker crust is the perfect combination of textures and flavors. Crumbl Cookie incorporates all of these things into their Key lime pie cookies. This copycat recipe does not miss a beat with a crisp cookie on the bottom, a tart key lime frosting, whipped cream, and a fresh lime wedge on top!

Banana bread is a sweet bread to make in the wintertime. These cozy and warm cookies deliver the same comfort a loaf of banana bread brings! Fluffy banana cookies are studded with chopped pecans and topped with sweet icing. Chopped pecans top the icing for an attractive look and texture to the soft cookies.

Oatmeal cookies always give me a sense of eating healthy. Even though they are packed with sugar, these oatmeal cookies provide a good source of fiber from the oats. The texture of oatmeal cookies is wonderful. The thin, sweet icing is like a glaze that covers the whole cookie for just the right amount of sweetness in every bite.

Crumbl Cookies are known for their ability to transform any dessert into a cookie. Cupcakes with chocolate frosting are a classic dessert served at many birthday parties. These large cookies easily take the place of the classic birthday party dessert. A classic vanilla cookie is piped with rich chocolate buttercream frosting and sprinkled with chocolate sprinkles for a classic cupcake look.

Cornbread is not a typical flavor you think would be a good cookie. Crumbl Cookie is known for its creative flavors, so why not have a cornbread cookie? Cornmeal is added to classic cookie ingredients to make these cornbread cookies. They're a great dessert take on classic Southern cornbread! A rich honey buttercream frosting is plopped onto the cookies and drizzled with more honey for the perfect touch of sweetness!

Birthday cake is a classic flavor that has been adapted for many desserts. Birthday cake cupcakes and ice cream are common flavors in the dessert industry. We can count on Crumbl Cookies to make a birthday cake-flavored cookie! Now you can make birthday cake cookies in your home with this Crumbl Cookie copycat recipe!

Sugar cookies are a classic cookie flavor. From classic round sugar cookies to fun shapes cut out during the holidays, sugar cookies are hard to beat. Crumbl Cookie does not stray from its classic round shape and thick frosting with these chilled sugar cookies. A delicious buttercream frosting is smeared onto a thick sugar cookie for a wonderful dessert for any occasion!

Every time fall rolls around I am on the lookout for new pumpkin desserts! In my search for Crumbl Cookie copycat recipes, I found this pumpkin cake cookie recipe. Soft, cake-like cookies are the perfect base for a sweet spiraled buttercream frosting. The attractive frosting is topped with mini chocolate chips for the perfect crunch to the fluffy cookies.

I love to make breakfast. Pancakes are one of my favorite breakfast foods, so I knew I had to include this buttermilk pancake Crumbl Cookie copycat recipe. Not only are they delicious cookies, but also adorable! A buttermilk cookie is baked to perfection and plopped with a buttercream frosting in the middle and drizzled with maple syrup for a cookie that looks like a miniature pancake!

Cotton candy is a popular festival dessert. I remember walking around the state fair as a kid eating a big blob of cotton candy on a stick. The flavor and texture of cotton candy are unmistakable. This Crumbl Cookie copycat cotton candy cookie recipe nails the cotton candy flavor in cookie form. Cotton candy extract brings the distinct cotton candy flavor and pink and blue gel food coloring brings the fun cotton candy colors to the icing.

If you are looking for a new Christmas cookie recipe, this is it! Peppermint is a classic winter flavor that brings the essence of the holidays with it. This Crumbl Cookie copycat peppermint bark cookie recipe features a chocolate cookie iced with peppermint frosting. The cookie is sprinkled with crushed candy canes for a fun crunch and extra peppermint flavor.

Hot chocolate marks the beginning of winter in my house. Every first snowfall I break out the hot chocolate mix and I and the kids enjoy some warm cocoa while watching a white blanket fall. These hot chocolate cookies bring all of that coziness to a cookie! A rich chocolate cookie is iced with a chocolate buttercream frosting and sprinkled with mini marshmallows to get the full hot chocolate effect. Pair this cookie with our favorite boozy hot chocolates for an adult treat.

Banana cream pie is native to the Midwest. It originated in the 19th century and quickly spread across the United States. This Crumble Cookie copycat banana cream pie cookie recipe captures the essence of banana pudding in a buttery crust. A soft cookie is topped with a sweet banana custard and topped with crunchy vanilla wafers.

Honey buns are known for their spiraled look and sweet flavor. This Crumbl Cookie copycat honey bun cookie recipe captures both of these aspects of a honey bun! Sweet, butter-flavored cookies are designed with a spiral and baked. A honey glaze covers the whole cookie, seeping in the cracks of the spiral for a sticky, delicious bite!

If you have young children, these Crumbl Blue Monster copycat cookies will be a new favorite! Large chocolate chip cookies are frosted with a bright blue buttercream frosting. These cookies are based on Sesame Street’s Cookie Monster. Crushed Chips Ahoy cookies are sprinkled on top for a crunchy bite.

My dad’s favorite dessert is pecan pie. I try to make one for him for his birthday every year, but this year I wanted to try something different. I found this Crumbl Cookie pecan pie cookie copycat recipe and knew it would be the perfect twist to his favorite dessert. These cookies are like mini pecan pies with a butter cookie crust!

One thing Crumbl Cookie does to come up with new cookie flavors is basing cookies on candy bars or other kinds of candy. This trick makes fans of that candy bar immediately try their new cookie flavor. These Twix Crumbl Cookie copycat cookies taste just like a Twix bar with soft cookies, caramel, and chocolate!

Another great way to get cookie flavor ideas is from cereal. Lucky Charms is a popular cereal that most people love, so why not make a cookie that tastes like the popular cereal? Rich cream cheese cookies are studded with white chocolate chips and crushed Lucky Charms marshmallows are topped with a marshmallow fluff frosting and sprinkled with Lucky Charms marshmallows.

Caramel is a popular dessert flavor. These caramel cheesecake cookies taste just like Crumbl Cookies caramel cheesecake cookies! A sandy cookie resembles the graham cracker crust of a cheesecake. A soft cream cheese icing is topped with a caramel glaze and sprinkled with flake salt for a salty ending to a sweet cookie.

Graham cracker crumbs combine with flour in these cherry cheesecake cookies. The graham cracker crust cookie is topped with a cream cheese cheesecake-like frosting. A graham cracker crust streusel adds some crunch to the cookies. Cherry pie filling adds the sweetness and tartness these cheesecake cookies need!

Molten lava cake is known for its rich chocolate that is still gooey in the center. These molten lava cookies bring that loved molten texture to cookie form with a chocolate cookie filled with hot fudge sauce. I love to serve these cookies on Valentine’s day with a side of strawberries!

These cookies are some of the Crumbl Cookies’ most attractive cookies in my opinion. A berry cookie is the perfect spring or summer dessert. A sweet cookie filled with blueberries is baked until soft. It is topped with homemade whipped cream and blueberry jam. The contrast of white whipped cream and dark blueberry jam looks lovely.

Similar to the Crumbl Cookies buttermilk cookies, these waffle cookies look like miniature waffles. A butter-based cookie is pressed to imitate a waffle. They are baked to perfection and topped with a buttercream frosting that looks like a dollop of butter. Maple syrup is drizzled on top for the finishing touch.

Gingerbread is another classic Christmas-time dessert flavor. I like the flavor so much that I make it all year round! These soft gingerbread cookies are topped with a sweet cream cheese frosting. Star sprinkles give them the finishing touch to make them resemble the Crumbl Cookies recipe.

Lemon poppy seed is one of my favorite summer flavors. The tart lemon brings the essence of the sun into a dessert. Lemon poppyseed bread is my go-to for lemon poppyseed desserts, but these cookies are a close second. These cookies are filled with lemon curd for a tart surprise in the middle!

If you are anything like me, eating raw cookie dough is your favorite part of baking chocolate chip cookies. This Crumbl Cookie copycat recipe is cookie dough lovers galore. A cookie dough cookie is topped with a cookie dough-flavored frosting and sprinkled with edible cookie dough balls and mini chocolate chips.

Of course, Crumbl had to make a cookie version of one of the most famous apple desserts. An oat-based cookie imitates the crust of the apple pie. A rich apple pie filling tops the crust-like cookies after they are baked. Small cookie bits are sprinkled on top of the cookie to take the place of the top crust of an apple pie!